Young Soldiers, Amazing Warriors by Robert H. Sholly

Robert H. Sholly’s Young Soldiers, Amazing Warriors: Inside One of the Most Highly Decorated Battalions of Vietnam (Stonywood Publications, 439 pp., $22.95, paper; $9.95, Kindle), his account of Company B, 1st Battalion, 8th Regiment, 4th Infantry Division in Vietnam in 1966-67, is a stunning read. In the book Sholly supplements his activities as Company Commander with the recollections of the men he led, as well as with military records.

The book’s combat scenes are relentlessly gory. Most of the battle descriptions come from the men who were engaged in the furious action. I had not read a book that described combat at such high and prolonged intensity since We Were Soldiers Once…and Young. Not coincidentally, the action in both books took place in the Ia Drang Valley area.

Early in his book, Sholly—a member of Vietnam Veterans of America— writes: “In my mind, just about everything in Vietnam was against us, the enemy, the terrain and the weather as well as Brigade and Division. My judgment was still out on Battalion.” A captain (and former sergeant), he was serving the first of two Vietnam War tours.

For months, alongside the 1st Battalion’s other companies, Sholly and his men trolled up and down the western border of South Vietnam to attract North Vietnamese Army forces deployed in Cambodia and Laos. “Whether in fishing or other endeavors, bait never has a good time,” Sholly says.

Even half a century later, the stories of B Company’s debilitating and relatively unproductive search-and-destroy missions made me curse the incompetence of the American political and military leaders who condoned using our soldiers as sitting ducks. At the same time, I admired the perseverance of the men—most of whom were draftees—in fulfilling their duties. As Sholly says, “Many GIs resented being out in the bush in a war they didn’t invent.”

Making the best from the rigors of the assignment, Sholly used long marches into the mountains and valleys west of Pleiku for on-the-job training. He bettered the marksmanship of new guys, taught all ranks to read maps, and refined his lieutenants’ and sergeants’ ability to call in artillery and air support.

“In the Central Highlands, our enemy were well-trained, main force NVA divisions and regiments that attacked in waves with mortar support,” Sholly writes. “They preferred to find U.S. companies and attack in superior number with two battalions, ensuring large American casualty numbers without regard to their own losses.

Robert H. Sholly“Once the enemy committed himself to the attack with larger forces than ours, our companies drew themselves into a perimeter and inflicted as much damage as possible while the brigade or division put forces into the area to block his escape into Cambodia or Laos. While this may have been smart tactics on the larger scale, at the company level it was hardly a favorite.”

The rules of engagement restricted Americans from getting closer than one kilometer from the border to prevent an international incident by accidentally operating in the next country, Sholly writes.

Things began really heating up in March 1967. First, the NVA massed its forces and overwhelmed Company A. Company B went to the rescue, but only by fighting its own small war along the way. Two months later, Company B fell into a similar trap and depended on support from Companies A and C, a situation that developed into a series of battles stretching over three days.

In each engagement, American forces were outnumbered—by as much as twenty-to-one—and outgunned until artillery and air support arrived. Both sides took high numbers of casualties. At the end of one encounter, Company B’s Fourth Platoon had only seven survivors.

As a result of these actions, the Medal of Honor was awarded to 1st Sgt. David McNerney, Platoon Sgt. Bruce Grandstaff, Staff Sgt. Frankie Molnar, and PFC Leslie Bellrichard. Three of the four were posthumous.

At times Young Soldiers, Amazing Warriors has a textbook quality as Sholly explains the requisites for a platoon, company, and battalion leader. An infantryman from start to finish, Sholly readily discusses both his successes and failures. In combat, he set the example by stepping into the middle of whatever challenges his men faced.

Sholly makes only brief editorial comments and lets facts tell the story. When he does speak emotionally, his sentiments reflect deep devotion to his men. After his Fourth Platoon was practically wiped out, he says, “Finally, in the dark, between mortar attacks, I grieved thinking about all the good men we had lost for who knew what.”

Robert Sholly’s military career spanned thirty-five years. He retired as a colonel.

The author’s website is http://youngsoldiersamazingwarriors.com

—Henry Zeybel

\

 

Hal Moore by Mike Guardia

Mike Guardia’s Hal Moore: A Soldier Once… And Always (Casemate, 229 pp., $32.95) is a concise, admiring biography of retired Army Lt. Gen. Harold “Hal” Moore. That is at should be, as there is a lot to admire about Hal Moore, who is best known for his outstanding leadership during the 1965 Battle of the Ia Drang Valley in Vietnam.

Author Mike Guardia, an active-duty Army officer and author (American Guerrilla, Shadow Commander), concentrates on Moore’s military career, beginning with his graduation from West Point in 1945 and highlighting his infantry service in the Korean War and in Vietnam.

Moore’s Vietnam War story has been told before, primarily in the two books he wrote with former Vietnam War correspondent Joe Galloway: the classic memoir We Were Soldiers Once… and Young, (1992), and We Are Soldiers Still (2008), the sequel that tells the back story of the battle and a 1993 TV documentary that brought Moore and Galloway back to the battlefield.

Mike Guardia

As we wrote in our review in print edition of The VVA Veteran: “Told in Moore’s strong first-person voice, this readable narrative goes over the basics of the November 1965 actions at Landing Zones X-Ray and Albany, the fiercest components of the 34-day Battle of the Ia Drang Valley.

“Moore, then a lieutenant colonel, showed exceptional courage and leadership as he saved his under-strength battalion from certain obliteration under a withering attack from a 2,000-man North Vietnamese Army regiment. Galloway, a UPI reporter, had a front-row seat for the vicious fight that lasted almost three days.

“In their new book, Moore and Galloway present revealing portraits of two former enemy commanders, Gens. Nguyen Huu An and Chu Huy Man, whom the authors met—and bonded with—in Vietnam nearly three decades after the battle.

“This book (along with its prequel and the Randall Wallace Hollywood film We Were Soldiers) proves that Hal Moore is an exceptionally thoughtful, compassionate, intelligent, and courageous leader of men. He was one of a handful of Army officers who studied the history of the Vietnam wars before he arrived. Since the war ended, he has been a strong voice for reconciliation and for honoring the sacrifices of the men with whom he served.”

Guardia leans heavily on the two books in his account of Moore’s life, along with interviews he conducted with his ninety-year-old subject, with members of his family, and with veterans who served with him.

—Marc Leepson